The Business Was Real. The Website Was Fake. And Customers Were the Target.
A California bagel shop discovered that criminals had copied its entire website to steal customers’ credit card information. Cybersecurity researchers say the operation is part of a sprawling network of fraudulent storefronts, and no business is too small to become the next victim.
Imagine opening your email one morning and discovering that someone has created an almost perfect copy of your company’s website.
Your logo is there. Your product photographs are there. Even your customer reviews have been copied.
But there’s one critical difference.
The website doesn’t belong to you, and the money customers spend there isn’t going to your business. Instead, criminals are collecting their credit card information.
That’s the nightmare that confronted Emily Winston, founder of California-based Boichik Bagels, when a longtime customer alerted her to a fraudulent website impersonating her business.
And according to cybersecurity researchers, her company is far from alone.
A Fake Bagel Shop Exposes a Massive Cybercrime Operation
As SFGATE reported on November 2, 2026, criminals created a convincing duplicate of the Boichik Bagels website, complete with the company’s distinctive branding, menu photographs, merchandise, and customer reviews.
To make the fraudulent store even more attractive, the scammers advertised products at discounts of approximately 65%.
The website address looked remarkably similar to the legitimate business’s domain name, making it easy for an unsuspecting shopper to overlook the difference.
When Winston investigated, she discovered additional fake versions of her company’s website.
What initially appeared to be an isolated incident was part of something much larger.
Selena Larson, a principal threat researcher at cybersecurity company Proofpoint, told SFGATE that she had identified approximately 50,000 websites sharing characteristics of the same fraudulent operation.
Other recognizable brands, including Ghirardelli Chocolate and the San Francisco 49ers, had also been impersonated.
The attackers weren’t necessarily breaking into legitimate websites. They were creating entirely separate counterfeit websites and using familiar brands to deceive customers.
That distinction is important because even a business with strong cybersecurity protections can have its identity stolen by criminals operating elsewhere on the internet.

Why Hack a Business When You Can Simply Copy It?
For years, businesses have been warned about ransomware, phishing attacks, stolen passwords, and data breaches.
Those threats remain serious, but website impersonation introduces a particularly frustrating cybersecurity challenge.
The criminals don’t necessarily need access to your servers, employees, or internal network.
They can take information that’s already publicly available, including your company name, photographs, product descriptions, and branding, and use it to build a fraudulent storefront.
They then register a similar-looking domain name and attempt to attract customers through search engines, advertisements, social media, or other online channels.
A customer believes they’re shopping with a trusted business, enters payment information, and unknowingly hands sensitive financial details to criminals.
In the campaign described by Proofpoint’s researcher, the fraudsters used a tool called PaymentVanilla to help collect credit card information through their counterfeit payment process.
The legitimate business may not even realize what’s happening until a customer reports a suspicious website or an unexplained transaction.
And by then, the damage may already be underway.
Artificial Intelligence Could Make the Problem Worse
Creating a convincing duplicate website once required some technical knowledge, design work, and considerable effort.
Today, automated tools make it easier to reproduce website layouts, copy product catalogs, generate descriptions, and deploy fraudulent pages at scale.
Artificial intelligence could accelerate that process even further.
AI-assisted systems can help produce convincing marketing text, adapt copied material, and generate variations of fraudulent websites more quickly than manual development.
Researchers suspect AI may be contributing to the scale of these operations, although its precise role in the Boichik Bagels impersonation campaign has not been conclusively established.
Regardless of whether every counterfeit site uses AI, the larger concern is clear.
Cybercriminals are developing ways to impersonate businesses faster and more cheaply, potentially overwhelming the ability of small companies to identify and remove fraudulent copies.
For a large corporation with dedicated cybersecurity personnel and brand protection teams, responding to website impersonation can already be challenging.
For a small business owner who handles marketing, customer service, and technology personally, the problem can become exhausting.
The Financial Damage Goes Beyond Stolen Credit Cards
When criminals impersonate a business, the immediate victims are often customers who unknowingly provide payment information to a fraudulent website.
But the legitimate company can suffer significant consequences, too.
Customers may blame the business for transactions it never processed. Negative reviews can spread. Customer service teams may become overwhelmed by complaints about orders the company never received.
And perhaps most damaging of all, the company’s reputation can suffer.
Consider a customer who believes they purchased a product from your website. The order never arrives, and their credit card is subsequently used for unauthorized purchases.
Will that customer investigate the difference between your legitimate website and the counterfeit version?
Or will they simply conclude that your business cannot be trusted?
That reputational risk is precisely what makes business impersonation so troubling.
The financial scale of the broader problem is considerable.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, consumers reported losing approximately $3.5 billion to impersonation scams in 2025, nearly three times the amount reported in 2020.
That figure covers multiple types of impersonation fraud, not just counterfeit shopping websites, but it illustrates how profitable pretending to be someone else has become for criminals.
Five Ways Businesses Can Protect Their Brand Online
Unfortunately, there’s no single cybersecurity product that can prevent criminals from copying publicly available information and creating a fake website.
However, businesses can take several practical steps to reduce their exposure and respond more effectively.
1. Monitor for Lookalike Websites
Periodically search for your business name, website address, and common variations of your domain.
Pay attention to unfamiliar websites advertising your products, unusually steep discounts, or domain names that differ from yours by only one character.
Businesses with greater exposure may benefit from automated domain monitoring and brand impersonation detection services.
2. Secure Your Legitimate Domain and Website
Make sure your domain registrar account is protected with multifactor authentication, strong unique passwords, and appropriate access restrictions.
Keep website software updated, restrict administrative privileges, and maintain secure backups.
These measures won’t prevent someone from copying your public website, but they help protect your actual website against compromise.
Businesses should also configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for their email domains to help reduce unauthorized email spoofing. These technologies protect email authentication; they do not prevent fraudulent websites from impersonating a brand.
3. Make Your Official Website Easy to Verify
Clearly identify your legitimate website through your business’s verified social media profiles, customer communications, and other trusted channels.
Encourage customers to bookmark your official website rather than relying entirely on advertisements or unfamiliar search results.
If your company sells products online, explain where customers can legitimately place orders and how they can verify suspicious promotions.
4. Have a Website Impersonation Response Plan
If you discover a counterfeit website, act quickly.
Preserve screenshots, suspicious domain information, and other evidence. Report the fraudulent website to the appropriate domain registrar, hosting provider, and relevant fraud reporting services.
Where appropriate, notify payment processors, search engines, and advertising platforms.
Warn customers through your established communication channels without unnecessarily promoting clickable links to the fraudulent site.
If customers may have entered payment information, advise them to contact their card issuer immediately.
5. Educate Employees and Customers
Employees who manage customer service, marketing, and social media should know how to recognize reports of brand impersonation and escalate them appropriately.
Customers should understand that a professional-looking website is not necessarily a legitimate website.
Even the familiar browser padlock and HTTPS connection do not establish that a company is genuine. They indicate an encrypted connection, not the trustworthiness of the organization operating the website.
The Better Business Bureau recommends checking website addresses carefully and researching unfamiliar sellers before completing purchases.
What If Your Business Is Already Being Impersonated?
The Boichik Bagels case demonstrates how quickly a relatively small business can find itself dealing with a cybersecurity problem it never anticipated.
Perhaps the most frustrating aspect is that taking down one fraudulent website doesn’t guarantee the problem is solved.
Criminals can register additional domains, recreate their storefronts, and continue targeting customers.
That makes ongoing monitoring and a repeatable response process especially important.
Businesses should document incidents, retain evidence, track takedown requests, and communicate consistently with customers.
They should also work with their technology and security providers to determine whether the impersonation is limited to external websites or whether there is evidence of a separate compromise involving company accounts, email, or systems.
These are different problems that require different responses.
Your Business Reputation Is Now Part of Your Cybersecurity Strategy
For many business owners, cybersecurity still means protecting computers, preventing ransomware, and keeping hackers out of their networks.
Those remain essential responsibilities.
But the rise of large-scale website impersonation is a reminder that an organization’s digital identity can be exploited even when its own systems haven’t been breached.
Criminals can steal the appearance of your business without stealing a single file from your network.
They can imitate your brand, advertise products you never offered, and collect payment information from people who believe they’re dealing with you.
And because these operations can be replicated at scale, small businesses are no longer too insignificant to attract attention.
The next major cybersecurity threat to your business might not begin with someone breaking into your website. It might begin with someone building another one that looks exactly like it.
Protecting Your Business in an Era of Digital Impersonation
At Alvarez Technology Group, we understand that cybersecurity is about more than protecting computers and networks. It’s also about preserving business continuity, protecting sensitive information, and maintaining the trust your customers place in your organization.
From managed IT services and cybersecurity protections to technology planning and employee awareness, a layered approach helps organizations prepare for an increasingly complicated threat environment.
As cybercriminals develop more sophisticated impersonation techniques, businesses need to understand both the threats to their internal systems and the risks to their online presence.
Is your business prepared for the next generation of online fraud?
Contact Alvarez Technology Group to discuss your organization’s cybersecurity strategy and how stronger technology protections can help reduce business risk.
Sources and further reading:
SFGATE: Boichik Bagels Among Bay Area Victims of Massive Online Credit Card Scam
Federal Trade Commission: 2025 Impersonation Scam Losses
Better Business Bureau: How to Identify Fake Websites

